Washington — Citing each ethical imperatives and considerations about accuracy, non secular groups are talking out in opposition to a brand new citizenship question slated to be included within the 2020 U.S. census.
The U.S. Department of Commerce, which oversees the census, introduced Monday (March 26) it will settle for a request made in December by the Department of Justice to incorporate a question about citizenship standing — one thing that hasn’t been on the necessary survey since 1950. In a press release, officers at Commerce argue the change is an try and implement the Voting Rights Act.
“Citizenship questions have also been included on prior decennial censuses,” the assertion reads partially. “Between 1820 and 1950, almost every decennial census asked a question on citizenship in some form.”
However, a number of non secular organizations — a lot of them progressive-leaning or representing minority faiths — see the choice as probably doing extra hurt than good to the census, which is used to find out the allocation of federal funds and the variety of seats every state has within the U.S. House of Representatives.
Tony Suarez, government vice chairman of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference and member of President Trump’s unofficial evangelical advisory board, appeared to criticize the census question not directly on Wednesday, arguing it evokes worry in immigrants as a result of Congress has but to cross immigration reform laws.
“The bottom line is we need to know who resides within our borders,” Suarez stated. “The census plays an important role in our way of life and government. Congress’ embarrassing 30-year streak of futility on the issue of immigration reform has led us to the point where a question regarding citizenship strikes instant fear in immigrant communities and visions of mass deportations. Congress must fix our broken immigration system, which in turn will bring people out of the shadows, allow a proper census and more importantly allow families to live the American dream without fear.”
Liberal non secular organizations and denominations have been extra forceful in expressing their displeasure.
Barbara Weinstein, director of the Commission on Social Action of Reform Judaism, issued a press release railing in opposition to the choice, referring to the “Jewish responsibility to support the engagement of all people.”
“We strongly condemn the Department of Commerce’s decision to include a question about citizenship on the 2020 Census,” Weinstein, whose denomination is the biggest Jewish one within the U.S., stated. “At a time when America’s immigrant communities feel increasingly threatened, the effects of this decision are not hard to foresee: Census response rates from immigrant communities will be suppressed, undermining the Census’s integrity overall.”
The Rev. John Dorhauer, common minister and president of the United Church of Christ, stated in an electronic mail the brand new citizenship question “is a not so subtle attempt to disenfranchise vulnerable communities and diminish their capacity to affect their political future.” The Rev. Jennifer Butler, CEO of the progressive faith-based group Faith in Public Life, derided the choice as a “discriminatory change.” Catholic nun Sr. Simone Campbell, head of Catholic social justice foyer NETWORK, invoked the Christian perception that each one individuals are created in God’s picture, saying in a press release that “implementing a question designed to suppress respondents is evidence of the Republican desire to control who matters in our country.”
One of essentially the most forceful critiques got here from the Council on American-Islamic Relations, whose information launch described the question as a part of the Trump administration’s “white supremacist agenda” designed to “drag our nation back to the false ‘white paradise’ of the 1950s.”
The criticisms echoed a letter despatched to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross on Jan. 10 by the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights — a coalition that features a number of religion groups. It requested him to reject the Department of Justice’s “untimely and unnecessary” request for a citizenship question on the census, saying doing so would “destroy any chance for an accurate count, discard years of careful research, and increase costs significantly.”
Signatories included an array of faith-based groups, such because the General Board of Church and Society for the United Methodist Church, Sikh Coalition, Franciscan Action Network, PICO California, Friends Committee on National Legislation (Quakers), National Advocacy Center of the Sisters of the Good Shepherd, Bread for the World, Church World Service and Interfaith Worker Justice, amongst others.
Other religion groups, such because the National Association of Evangelicals, National Council of Churches, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops didn’t instantly problem statements or reply to requests for remark.
The faith-based criticisms add to the outcry of a number of political leaders. At least 12 states plan to sue the Trump administration over the change, arguing it violates the Constitution and fewer individuals will take part.
The White House redirected requests for remark to officers on the Department of Commerce, who didn’t instantly reply.